Barnum & Belugas
Believing in Belugas
How the Beluga Business Began
My Life with the Belugas
Smart, Chatty and Chirpy – and That’s Their Problem
Visiting with Belugas in the Wild
The Legal and Moral Issues
What You Can Do
Contact Information for the Georgia Aquarium.
Questions for the Georgia Aquarium and the NMFS.
Notes and Talking Points for letters, e-mails, phone calls and general discussion
(Third in a series on belugas in captivity.) One day in 1861, 11-year-old Sarah Putnam wrote in her diary:
“I went again to the Aquarial Gardens and there we saw the Whale being driven by a girl. She was in a boat and the Whale was fastened to the boat by a pair of rains [sic], and a collar, which was fastened round his neck. The men had to chase him before they could put on the collar.” (the Massachusetts Historical Society)
What Sarah had seen that day was one of the first beluga whales to be captured and put on display in the United States.
For several years, entrepreneurs and adventurers, including the infamous P.T. Barnum, had been scrambling to be the first to exhibit whales. Sarah had seen this beluga at the Boston Aquarial Gardens, which had opened in 1859. William E. Damon’s 1879 book Ocean Wonders: a Companion for the Seaside describes the same thing:
The first [whale] ever captured for such a purpose was secured by Prof. H. D. Butler, who brought it in perfect health to Boston, Massachusetts, where it was kept in an immense glass reservoir. …
It continued in good condition for more than a year, and became so perfectly acclimated to its new home that it actually showed some signs of intelligence. There was a nautilus shaped boat made, to which he was occasionally tackled and taught to draw. I fancy he was not very fond of being treated like a draught-horse; for when we wanted him to “hold up” to be harnessed, he just put on speed and went all the faster around his glass-walled circle.
He would, however, sometimes condescend to take a live herring or a squirming eel from my hand, and then, turning on one side, sail around and look for more of the same sort; and in other ways he would show that he was really becoming an intelligent Americanized citizen.
If the whale Damon wrote about really survived a year, that would have been a very long time for the industry in those days. Some of the belugas didn’t even survive beyond a few hours. More likely, then, this one soon died and would have been replaced by another, probably several others, as the year went on.
P.T. Barnum (right) exhibited the first two belugas he’d captured in Boston 1861, and then drove them to the American Museum in New York where they died a day or two later. Barnum was proud of himself regardless. He didn’t need to worry about the belugas dying; after all, there were thousands more to be found where these had come from in the St. Lawrence Seaway. He wrote:
Even in this brief period, thousands availed themselves of the opportunity of witnessing this rare sight. Since August I have brought two more whales to New-York, at an enormous expense, but both died before I could get them into the Museum.
A fifth living whale has now arrived here, and will remain in the Museum as long as he lives. Perhaps this will be but a few hours, but in order to prolong his life as long as possible, I have, at an expense of $7,000, laid a six-inch cast-iron pipe from the river to the Museum, through Fulton-street and Broadway, and by means of a powerful steam-engine working night and day, the whale is constantly supplied with pure salt water at the rate of three hundred gallons per minute.
This whale (some fifteen feet long) is undoubtedly the greatest “blower” in New-York. I leave this monster leviathan to do his own “spouting,” not doubting that the public will embrace the earliest moment (before it is forever too late) to witness the most novel and extraordinary exhibition ever offered them in this City.”
Over the next four years, at least nine whales were displayed at the Museum. None of them survived long, and in 1865 the two remaining belugas died when the entire Museum went up in flames.
More museums and aquariums were now springing up, along with businesses that made their money by keeping belugas in holding areas in Canada so they could be quickly shipped down to the new marine zoos whenever one who was on display died. (Today, U.S. marine zoos still treat their Canadian counterparts as a holding area or warehouse for restocking their tanks when captive whales and dolphins die.)
In Appleton’s Popular Science Monthly (July 1899), Fred Mather writes about belugas at the Coney island aquarium that he managed:
The management would keep whales penned up in the St. Lawrence River to replace those which died, and would never show more than two at a time, claiming that they were rare animals and only to be had at an “enormous expense”. … It would never do to have the public know that they were common in the St. Lawrence in the summer, and when one was getting weak, another would be sent down, and the public supposed the same pair was on exhibition all the time.
Of one of the belugas who had died less than a month after arriving, Mather wrote that he sounded hoarse and had a kind of cough, and that his female companion “slackened her pace day by day to accommodate it to that of her constantly weakening companion, and as the end neared she put her broad traverse tail under his and propelled him along.” His female companion was then sent across the Atlantic to the Royal Aquarium in London, where she died four days later.
By the end of the 19th Century, many of the aquariums were closing down. Barnum and several of his competitors had died, the novelty of seeing belugas in a tank was waning, and then came the Great Depression. But in the late 1950s, the beluga industry started to picked up again. Alaska quickly became the favored place to capture belugas from their families, and in June 1958 two belugas, Louey and Bertha, were captured off the Alaska coast and put on a plane to New York. They died on the plane about an hour before landing.
His female companion was sent across the Atlantic to the Royal Aquarium in London, where she died four days later.But the captivity industry persisted, and a new generation of marine zoos, including SeaWorld and the Georgia, Shedd and Mystic aquariums, along with other notorious sea circuses like Marineland in Ontario, found more successful ways to capture belugas, ship them to their display tanks, and keep them alive longer that P.T. Barnum had been able to manage.
Regardless of the industry’s new techniques, however, today’s marine zoos continue to have serious problems keeping belugas alive. While a beluga in the wild can expect to live up to 60 years or more, few adults in captivity few adults live beyond the age of 25, and many baby belugas born in captivity don’t survive beyond a few days.
With just 31 belugas still living at marine zoos in the United States, there’s now an urgency to import a fresh population in order to keep the beluga business going.
And that’s why the Georgia Aquarium has arranged the capture of 18 belugas from the Sea of Okhotsk in Russia, where it’s holding them in hopes of getting a permit to bring them to the United States. They plan to keep six for themselves and to send the rest to three SeaWorld circuses, to the Shedd Aquarium in Chicago, and probably to the Mystic Aquarium in Connecticut.
The Georgia Aquarium has applied for a permit to import 18 beluga whales from Russia into the United States. If it is approved, this will be the first time since 1993 that an aquarium or marine circus has imported animals directly from the wild. It will set a major precedent and return us to a time before public outcry forced the captivity industry to agree to stop capturing marine mammals to put on display.